Caution workforce in the road!
What would your reaction be if the workforce in the road, fixing the road, did not have any tools or machines to do the job?
Frustration at the waste of time in the resulting traffic queue?
What would be your reaction if the washing machine repair man turned up without his tool kit, without a diagram of the appliance and without access to spare parts?
Refuse to pay the bill?
A security company providing security without enough staff
Questions in Parliament?
How is that so many Enterprise Architects can do their job without the tools of their trade?
Often Enterprise Architects are missing vital parts of their tool kit:
- Reference architectures
- Models of the Organisation
- Application Landscape
- Analysis and design tools
- Information sources to feed the analysis tools
- Stakeholder analysis
Worse than this they seem to lack the basic tools to be able to create the EA tools they need such as the processes to maintain the models, principles, guidance and governance.
Do you wonder why EA gets a bad name?
I am not suggesting that we go back to the old EA approaches
- Boil the ocean documenting the current state
- Tons of detailed standards (always out of date)
- Heavy handed governance that increases costs, misses deadlines and the point
And any of the other EA anti-patterns
Togaf 9.x of course points us at lots of artefacts and things to do, it is supposed to. We do not have to do them all, we can mix and match – What happens when we mix and match ourselves out of TOGAF9.x in all but name? Are we no longer doing architecture?
There are precedents for this situation:
SSADM was created and adopted, but everyone picked the bits they liked or could do. No one could afford to complete the whole SSADM – Especially with paper and pencil (there were few tools around). SSADM became discredited; Every claim of compliance was subject to interpretation.
A similar thing happened to PRINCE.
I guess that there are many other examples of the dilution of the good practices until they are no longer effective.
Will this be the fate of TOGAF?
Are we architects no longer doing architecture?