I’ve just attended a webinar panel discussion run by eBizQ about Web 2.0 and SOA.
I found the relationship between the two subjects kinda hard to see, hence I attended the webinar to understand it better. I wasn’t much more convinced afterwards. However, one interesting point was that as we expose more and more services in an enterprise, then users can create their own mashups from a variety of data sources, so I can see this relationship. This has the potential to create chaos as users compose their own ’super-services’ though – with usage of underlying services becoming unpredictable and harder to manage.
Another interesting point made by one of the panelists was that Web 2.0 provides the presentation layer on top of an SOA – and whereas the services of an SOA is the technology part of an enterprise architecture, Web 2.0 provides the ‘human’ part. By this I took it that he meant that users can create their own compositions of other services which are customised for them, and would never be identified as good candidates for reuse and so would never exist otherwise.
A lot of the webinar really focused on web 2.0 and what a good thing it can be for an enterprise, which I agree with. My pride was somewhat hurt though as my question to the panel (asking about productivity concerns with offering Facebook/IM etc inside the enterprise, with users “throwing bananas” at each other rather than working) was thoroughly ridiculed by the panel…
(
March 23, 2008 at 9:47 am
Well, throwing bananas sounds a bit ‘zoo’, throwing sheep is more ‘farmyard’ and endless nudges more like naughty schoolkids – and all of these are unproductive in a business environment. So why were you ridiculed? Perhaps these are the ’services’ desired by your webinar attendees…
March 23, 2008 at 10:19 am
Dunno – maybe they didn’t listen to my question correctly – plus, as you say, all the panelists were from vendors of products/services in this area. They were being open in their comments in general though. Their answer focused on the productivity benefits of Web 2.0 in the enterprise, rather than the management of misuse which I was asking about. One guy said that he wasn’t aware of any study in the last 2 years that had shown productivity loss.
April 2, 2008 at 9:44 am
A summary article and reader comments on silicon.com that may provide alternative views on this.
http://networks.silicon.com/webwatch/0,39024667,39161662,00.htm